Chargebacks raise practical questions fast. Is this a formal dispute? How long do you have? Should you contact the customer? Which records matter? Answer those before someone on the team starts attaching files at random.
Here are eight questions online merchants can work through before replying. The answer may depend on your processor, card network, dispute type, and country. Use the instructions in the specific case as your guide.

The Online Merchant Chargeback Response Prompts book has prompt patterns for organizing case details. For a full evidence process, read the response prep guide.
1. Is this an inquiry or a formal dispute?
Check the exact status in your processor’s account. Stripe describes inquiries as a pre-dispute stage, often used when a cardholder does not recognize a transaction. A prompt response at that stage may help explain the charge and prevent escalation.
Stripe also says that if an inquiry escalates to a formal chargeback, you must submit another response for the dispute. That is Stripe’s process. Check what your provider expects and do not assume that replying to an inquiry closes a later case.
2. What does the cardholder say happened?
Read the claim details and any documents the provider makes available. Is the issue that the order did not arrive, the item differed from its description, a refund was expected, or the transaction was not recognized? The category and the customer’s explanation both matter.
Stripe recommends reviewing the dispute category and available claim details before choosing evidence. Do not paste a response from another case without checking whether it addresses this complaint.
3. What is the deadline shown for this case?
Use the case screen, not a blog post or old calendar reminder. Stripe says its response windows are usually 7 to 21 days depending on the network. The window can vary, and a processor may set its own operational cutoff before the network deadline.
Write down the due date and time zone. Assign one person to keep track. If another team has to find a file, request it now.
4. Which transaction and order are we discussing?
Match the transaction reference, amount, currency, date, order number, product, and account. If the cardholder name differs from the recipient or business name, note the relationship only if your records show it.
This check matters when a customer has placed multiple orders. A carrier receipt for a different package will not answer the current claim.
5. What records directly answer the claim?
Ask what each record proves. An order receipt may show what was purchased. A carrier scan may show an event for a tracking number. A support message may show what was discussed. A refund record may show an amount and date. One file does not automatically prove every part of the transaction.
| Claim type shown in the case | Records to check | Question for your reviewer |
|---|---|---|
| Merchandise or service not received | Fulfillment, shipment, service access or completion records | Does the source match the order and delivery or service details? |
| Not as described or defective | Product listing, agreed specifications, customer messages, return records | Does this show what was offered and what the customer reported? |
| Credit or refund issue | Refund transaction, credit notice, billing ledger | Was the credit actually processed and for the right amount? |
| Unrecognized transaction | Order details and relevant account or transaction records | Does the record tie this purchase to the account without exposing unnecessary data? |
This is a working aid, not a network evidence checklist. Follow the current fields in the case form. Visa rules list different response requirements by dispute condition, and the rules can change.
6. Should we contact the customer?
Check whether your provider offers a contact route and whether it is appropriate for this case. A calm question may clarify an unfamiliar billing descriptor or an unresolved return. Keep a record of what was said and any refund, replacement, or other action you took.
Do not pressure the customer or ask them to withdraw a claim in a way that conflicts with your provider’s rules. Keep the formal response process moving while you communicate.
7. Should we accept the dispute or challenge it?
Review the claim, the available evidence, the amount, and the costs and rules for a response. You can ask a broker, payment provider, or qualified adviser to explain options when the case is significant. AI cannot determine the right commercial or legal choice for your business.
If you do challenge it, make sure the evidence addresses the actual claim and follows the provider’s current requirements. An accusation or a confident tone does not replace supporting records.
8. Can you edit or add evidence after you submit?
Check before you click. Stripe says a Dashboard response is sent to the issuing bank and cannot be edited or supplemented afterward. Other platforms and dispute stages may work differently. Save the exact final packet and submission confirmation.
Visa’s current Core Rules and Product and Service Rules describe dispute responses by condition. Pair the current network rules with your own provider’s instructions, which explain how your account submits the case.
Make a short case note before you reply
Write down the claim, due date, evidence owner, open questions, and chosen action. Keep the source documents beside the note. If you use AI to make a timeline or evidence index, check it against the originals and remove sensitive information from unapproved tools.
- What is the exact case status?
- What fact would answer the stated complaint?
- Which source supports each sentence you plan to submit?
- Who has reviewed the file?
- What does the provider say happens after submission?
For the response sequence, follow the eight-step workflow. Avoid the seven evidence and submission mistakes and use the timeline and evidence templates to keep the file easy to review. The AI prompt guide and the Online Merchant Chargeback Response Prompts book can help your team ask better questions of its own records.
Frequently asked questions
Is a payment inquiry the same as a chargeback?
Not always. Stripe describes inquiries as a pre-dispute stage that may let a merchant clarify a transaction before a formal dispute. Check your provider’s case status.
How long do I have to answer a chargeback?
Use the deadline shown for the case. Stripe says its response windows are usually 7 to 21 days depending on the card network.
Should I contact the customer after a chargeback?
If your provider offers a route, a factual conversation may help. Keep a record and still follow the formal response process and deadline.
Can I submit more evidence later?
It depends on the provider and stage. Stripe says Dashboard responses cannot be edited or supplemented after submission.
Will a detailed response make me win?
No. The issuer or network decides under its rules. Relevant evidence helps review but cannot guarantee the outcome.