When an audit worksheet shows a code or payroll change you do not understand, start with one clean question: which record and rule led to this line? The answer helps you decide whether the entry is correct, incomplete, or worth disputing.
Here are eight questions contractors can ask their auditor, broker, or insurer before replying. The details depend on the policy and state. Use California Department of Insurance and NCCI material below only within the scope of those sources.

If you are preparing the file, read the contractor payroll audit guide and the Workers’ Comp Audit Prompts book. This Q&A is for small U.S. contractors and does not replace advice from a licensed insurance professional.
1. What policy period and date basis are you using?
Confirm the policy start and end dates. Then ask whether the auditor wants payroll by pay date, work date, or another basis. Your tax records may use calendar quarters while the policy follows a different period.
If the ranges differ, provide the report you have and show where it starts and ends. Ask what reconciliation the auditor needs. Don’t change the date filter without leaving a record of the original report.
2. Which source supports this payroll amount?
For an amount that does not match your books, ask for the worksheet line, dates, source record, and calculation. Then compare it with your payroll register, timecards, tax filings, and job cost report.
Be specific. “This number looks wrong” is hard to answer. “Can you show which dates make up line 6? Our policy-period register has a different total” gives the reviewer somewhere to start.
3. What actual work led to this class code?
Ask which operation or job duties the classification reflects. Keep your question tied to the audit period, because a company may have changed its work since then. Share accurate job descriptions, crew assignments, time records, and project notes.
California’s Department of Insurance workers’ compensation guide says California employers who question an assigned code should contact their broker-agent or insurer for an explanation. That is California guidance. Other states may use different classification systems or review routes.
4. How did you handle work that changed during the year?
If an employee moved between tasks or crews, ask what records the auditor used for those dates and whether the classification treatment reflects the actual work. Bring the original assignment and time records, not a new summary that cannot be checked.
Ask which rule or policy provision governs any payroll allocation. Do not assume a particular split is allowed. The answer may depend on the state, classification plan, and records kept during the work.
5. What subcontractor documents are missing?
Ask the auditor to identify each subcontractor, period, document, and record that remains open. You may have an agreement in one folder, invoices in another, and a certificate with different dates. A precise list makes the follow-up manageable.
Ask how the insurer will review the work arrangement and coverage records under the applicable policy and state rules. Do not assume a certificate resolves every question or that all subcontractors are treated the same.
6. Can I see the worksheet behind this change?
Ask for the detailed audit worksheet and any supporting calculations or source records that the insurer can provide. Review the line item, policy period, payroll amount, code, and explanation. Keep the original worksheet alongside the revised one.
If the explanation uses a term you do not understand, ask the broker or insurer to define it and cite the policy or classification rule. The goal is to understand the decision before you accept or dispute it.
7. What is the process and deadline if I disagree?
Ask who handles a written question, where to send it, and when a formal dispute must be filed. Keep the answer in writing. State procedures differ, and a broker or insurer may have a specific review path.
NCCI describes a dispute resolution process for matters in its system. It notes that classification disputes may involve an operational inspection, and that an inspection of current operations may not match the period under dispute. Keep period-specific records and confirm whether your state uses NCCI for the issue.
8. What do you need from us to close the audit?
Ask for a complete list of open items, acceptable formats, and how you will know each item was received. Send a clear index and save the submission confirmation. If a document does not exist, say so and ask whether a substitute record is acceptable.
A question list for your next call
| Topic | Ask this | Have ready |
|---|---|---|
| Payroll | What dates and source make up this total? | Payroll register and reconciliation |
| Classification | Which operations and duties support this code? | Job notes, timecards, crew assignments |
| Subcontractor | Which record and date range is still needed? | Agreement, invoices, coverage documents |
| Dispute route | Who reviews the concern and by what date? | Policy, worksheet, written audit request |
After the call, write down the date, who answered, what they said, and any promised follow-up. Keep it factual. If you still disagree, ask your broker or a qualified advisor to review the policy and evidence before you file a formal dispute.
Let AI help prepare, then check every line
With company approval, AI can organize the facts for your call. Remove personal and tax information from anything you share with an unapproved tool.
“Using only the records and audit worksheet below, prepare a list of questions for the auditor. For each question, include the worksheet line, policy period, source record, and specific mismatch. Do not determine the correct class code, decide whether payroll is included, infer a state deadline, or claim the insurer made an error. Mark any missing information I need to obtain.”
Read the questions against the original files. AI can confuse a premium amount with a payroll amount or mistake a pay date for a work date. The owner or broker should approve anything you send.
For six common record problems, see the audit mistakes guide. Follow the eight-step workflow to prepare the file, and use the audit templates for payroll and subcontractor tracking. The Workers’ Comp Audit Prompts book includes more structured ways to review the records.
Frequently asked questions
What period does a workers’ compensation audit cover?
Check the request and policy documents for the period and date basis. Ask how to handle payroll or tax records that use other dates.
Can I ask why a class code was assigned?
Yes. Ask for the classification basis and supporting worksheet. California DOI gives this direction for California employers; confirm the process in your state.
What should I ask about subcontractor payroll?
Ask which subcontractor records and coverage documents are needed, what dates apply, and how the insurer will evaluate exposure under your policy and state rules.
Can a current site inspection prove what employees did last year?
Not by itself. NCCI notes that current operations may differ from the policy period under dispute. Keep records from the actual period.
Can AI write my audit dispute?
It can organize facts or draft questions, but check the policy, source records, state process, and deadlines before sending a response.